India’s leading news agency, Asian News International (ANI), has filed a lawsuit against OpenAI. This case could set a major precedent for how AI companies use copyrighted content in India. On November 18, 2024, ANI filed a 287-page lawsuit in the Delhi High Court. It accuses OpenAI of using its content without permission to train AI models like ChatGPT.
The lawsuit also claims OpenAI generated false information attributed to ANI. One of the most alarming allegations is that ChatGPT produced a fake interview with Rahul Gandhi, a prominent Indian politician. ANI says these “hallucinations” damage its credibility and could spread misinformation to the public.
What’s at Stake?
ANI argues that OpenAI’s use of its content without consent violates copyright laws. The agency believes that the spread of false information through AI could harm its reputation and cause public confusion. This is especially concerning given the increasing reliance on AI-generated content in the media.
Early Court Proceedings
At a hearing on November 19, 2024, Justice Amit Bansal issued a summons to OpenAI. The company confirmed it had stopped ChatGPT from accessing ANI’s website for content. However, the judge didn’t grant an immediate injunction. He said the case was too complex and required more time. The next hearing is scheduled for January.
OpenAI’s Defense
OpenAI’s lawyer, Amit Sibal, defended the company’s practices. He argued that copyright laws do not protect facts. He also noted that websites can opt out of having their content used by AI models. OpenAI maintains that it does not have servers in India and that the lawsuit lacks jurisdiction.
ANI’s Concerns
ANI’s lawyer, Sidhant Kumar, disagreed with OpenAI’s arguments. He pointed out that just because content is publicly available doesn’t mean it can be freely used by AI companies. Kumar emphasized that ANI is concerned about the spread of fake news, especially when it’s attributed to their agency. He stressed that this could lead to significant harm to ANI’s reputation.
A Growing Global Debate
This lawsuit is part of a larger global conversation about how AI companies use copyrighted content. OpenAI is facing similar lawsuits in the United States, Canada, and Germany. News agencies and content creators are increasingly concerned about the accuracy of AI-generated content and the potential for misinformation.
What Happens Next?
The Delhi High Court plans to appoint an independent expert to advise on the copyright issues surrounding AI models. This expert will help the court understand how AI systems use publicly available content. The court will also examine how news content spreads across platforms.
If ANI wins, it could change the way AI companies operate in India and beyond. Other media organizations might follow suit, leading to more legal challenges for OpenAI. On the other hand, if OpenAI wins, it could open the door for AI companies to continue using public content without restriction.
The Big Picture
- What’s at stake: ANI’s lawsuit challenges OpenAI’s use of copyrighted content for AI training, citing false information and damage to reputation.
- Key players: ANI, OpenAI, and the Delhi High Court.
- Legal arguments: ANI argues that public availability doesn’t give AI companies free access, while OpenAI claims it uses facts that aren’t protected by copyright.
- Global context: The case adds to the growing number of lawsuits against AI companies, raising questions about copyright and AI’s role in content creation.
This case is just the beginning. The outcome could have a major impact on how AI companies use content in the future.
Weekly AI essentials. Brief, bold, brilliant. Always free. Learn how to use AI tools to their maximum potential and access our AI resources to help you grow. 👇
